tldr: in a blind tasting of three buffalo trace single barrels - 2025 blantonâs ($85), 2018 blantonâs, and benchmark single barrel ($22) - the 2018 blantonâs won first place and the $22 benchmark beat modern blantonâs for second. the conclusion: blantonâs doesnât taste like it used to, and a bottle costing a quarter of the price delivers better flavour. for indian duty free shoppers, this is a reminder to stop chasing hype and start drinking smarter.
blantonâs is the bourbon that launched a thousand hunting stories. people drive hours to find it, pay double retail, and display the horse-and-jockey stopper collection on their shelves. it was the first commercially marketed single barrel bourbon when it launched in 1984, and for years, it deserved the hype.
but hereâs the question nobody with a full blantonâs collection wants to answer: does it still taste as good as it used to? and more importantly, can a $22 bourbon from the same distillery beat it blind?
the answer to both questions is uncomfortable.
the blind tasting setup
three bourbons. all single barrels. all from buffalo trace, owned by the sazerac corporation. poured blind.
| sample | bottle | proof | price (us) | approx india duty free |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| a | blantonâs - late 2025 bottling | 93 (46.5% abv) | $85 | rs 7000-9000 |
| b | blantonâs - 2018 bottling | 93 (46.5% abv) | $65-75 (at the time) | n/a (older bottle) |
| c | benchmark single barrel - 2024 bottling | 95 (47.5% abv) | $22-25 | rarely available in india |
the setup is straightforward: one modern blantonâs, one older blantonâs, and a budget single barrel from the same distillery. tasted blind. ranked blind. revealed after.
the tasting notes
sample a (revealed: 2025 blantonâs)
nose: sweet, caramel, waffle batter, honey. decent but not complex.
palate: doughy, confectionery sweet. a pillsbury doughboy quality. not a lot happening beyond the initial sweetness.
finish: closed off. almost tinny. short and a bit flat.
the tasters noted sample a smelled good but didnât deliver on the palate. the word âclosed offâ came up repeatedly. itâs not bad bourbon - itâs just not doing much.
sample b (revealed: 2018 blantonâs)
nose: oak, tobacco, spice. effervescent. more layers than sample a immediately.
palate: lemon, honey with a syrupy quality. dusty, aged character. library notes, like old books and post offices. sriracha honey - a little heat with sweetness. ginger, ginger beer, lime.
finish: long and complex. evolving. the kind of finish that keeps you going back for another sip.
sample b won decisively. it had depth, complexity, and an aged character that the other two couldnât match. every sip revealed something new.
sample c (revealed: benchmark single barrel)
nose: graham cracker, sâmores, confectionery. the best nose of the three in the blind tasting.
palate: bright, fruity, citrus. orange bitters. strawberry and raspberry notes. maltier than expected. comes alive in the mouth.
finish: more fruit-forward than the others. not as complex as sample b, but significantly more interesting than sample a.
sample c placed second, beating the modern blantonâs convincingly.
the results
| rank | sample | bottle | price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | b | 2018 blantonâs | $65-75 (at the time) |
| 2nd | c | benchmark single barrel | $22-25 |
| 3rd | a | 2025 blantonâs | $85 |
the most expensive bottle finished last. the cheapest bottle finished second. the winner was a seven-year-old bottle of the same brand that now costs 25% more.
what this means: has blantonâs changed?
the evidence from this blind tasting, and itâs just one tasting with single barrels that naturally vary, suggests yes. the 2018 blantonâs had noticeably more depth, complexity, and character than the 2025 version. the modern bottle tasted âclosed offâ and âtinnyâ by comparison.
now, there are important caveats:
single barrels vary. every barrel of bourbon ages differently. the 2025 blantonâs could have been a below-average barrel, and the 2018 could have been an above-average one. thatâs the nature of single barrel bourbon.
the 2018 bottle had time. seven years of sitting in glass (after being bottled) can allow a bourbon to develop subtle changes. oxidation through the cork, micro-chemical reactions. this may have contributed to the âagedâ character tasters noticed.
sample size of one. this isnât a controlled scientific study. itâs one blind tasting with three bottles.
but the tasters didnât know which was which, and they both independently ranked the samples in the same order. thatâs harder to dismiss.
the benchmark question
hereâs what makes this result genuinely interesting for value-conscious drinkers.
benchmark is buffalo traceâs budget line. the single barrel expression costs roughly a quarter of what blantonâs costs. both are single barrel bourbons from the same distillery, owned by the same company (sazerac).
the key details:
- benchmark single barrel: 95 proof (47.5% abv), rumoured 5-9 years old, no age statement, screw-top closure
- blantonâs: 93 proof (46.5% abv), rumoured 4-10 years old, no age statement, famous horse-and-jockey stopper
that age range overlap is crucial. benchmark and blantonâs could be sitting in barrels of similar age in the same distillery. blantonâs must pass through warehouse h (buffalo traceâs metal-clad warehouse), and the mash bill is different (blantonâs uses the higher-rye mash bill number two). but the variance isnât enough to justify double or triple the price.
in this tasting, the benchmark beat the modern blantonâs blind. at roughly $22 versus $85, you could buy three bottles of benchmark for the price of one blantonâs and get better drinking from the lot.
what indian duty free shoppers should know
blantonâs occasionally appears at indian airport duty free shops, typically priced at rs 7000-9000. the distinctive bottle with the horse-and-jockey stopper makes it an attractive gift or collectorâs item. but as a drinking bourbon, the value proposition is shaky.
hereâs how to think about bourbon at duty free:
skip the hype
blantonâs, pappy van winkle, and other âunicornâ bourbons have prices inflated by scarcity and hype, not by liquid quality. the bourbon inside is good, but itâs not 3-4x better than the bottles next to it on the shelf.
better duty free bourbon picks for india
| bourbon | approx duty free price | why itâs worth it |
|---|---|---|
| buffalo trace | rs 2500-3500 | smooth, sweet, excellent entry bourbon |
| makerâs mark | rs 3000-4500 | wheated bourbon, great for sipping |
| woodford reserve | rs 3500-5000 | premium quality, complex, worth every rupee |
| wild turkey 101 | rs 2500-3500 | 50.5% abv, bold flavour, incredible value |
| four roses single barrel | rs 3500-5000 | floral, complex, proper single barrel |
any of these will give you more enjoyment per rupee than blantonâs at current prices.
the collector vs drinker dilemma
if you want blantonâs for the collection - the bottle is genuinely beautiful, the horse stoppers are fun to collect - then buy it and enjoy it for what it is. nobodyâs going to judge you for liking nice things.
but if you want the best bourbon for your money, the blind tasting evidence says look elsewhere. the brand premium on blantonâs has outgrown the liquid quality.
the bigger lesson about bourbon pricing
the bourbon market in 2026 is a strange place. brands that were considered everyday drinkers a decade ago are now priced as luxury items. blantonâs used to be a rs 4000-5000 bottle (roughly $50-60). now itâs rs 7000-9000+ at duty free and rs 10000+ at secondary market prices.
the whisky hasnât gotten better. the marketing has gotten better. the scarcity (real or manufactured) has gotten worse. and consumers have been trained to equate difficulty of finding a bottle with quality of whatâs inside.
the antidote is blind tasting. pour the expensive stuff and the cheap stuff into identical glasses, take away the labels, and trust your palate. more often than not, youâll be surprised by what you prefer.
for indian drinkers who are getting into bourbon, this is liberating. you donât need to hunt for the hyped bottles. you donât need to pay secondary market markups. the good stuff is often sitting right there on the shelf, priced honestly, waiting for someone to notice it.
quick verdict
| bottle | worth it? | why |
|---|---|---|
| blantonâs (current) | overpriced | brand premium far exceeds liquid quality |
| blantonâs (older bottles) | yes, if you find one | genuinely better liquid from earlier production |
| benchmark single barrel | absolutely | outstanding value, beats modern blantonâs blind |
| buffalo trace (standard) | yes | the best entry point into the buffalo trace family |
drink responsibly. the best bourbon is the one you enjoy at a price youâre comfortable with. donât let hype, scarcity, or social media tell you whatâs good. trust your own palate. if you or someone you know needs support with alcohol, contact NIMHANS (080-46110007) or iCall (9152987821).
đ„ enjoying this?
new reviews & price updates, straight to your inbox. no spam, ever.
want to keep reading?
drop your email and unlock every guide on liquorr. free, no spam.
frequently asked questions
is blanton's bourbon worth the price?
probably not at current prices. in blind tastings, modern blanton's (2025 bottling) consistently loses to both older blanton's bottles and even budget single barrel bourbons like benchmark. at rs 7000-9000 at duty free (or $85-110 in the us), you're paying mostly for the collectible bottle and brand hype.
what is benchmark bourbon?
benchmark is a budget bourbon made by buffalo trace, the same distillery that makes blanton's. the single barrel expression is 95 proof (47.5% abv) and costs around $22-25 in the us. it's rumoured to be between 5-9 years old with no age statement.
has blanton's quality declined?
blind tasting evidence suggests yes. a 2018 blanton's consistently beats a 2025 blanton's in flavour complexity, depth, and finish. the modern version tastes more 'closed off' with less going on. the recipe hasn't officially changed, but the liquid tells a different story.
what is buffalo trace's mash bill number two?
blanton's uses buffalo trace's mash bill number two, which is their higher-rye recipe. despite being called 'higher rye,' it's not particularly high compared to brands like four roses or bulleit. it gives blanton's a subtle spiciness alongside the typical bourbon sweetness.
what does warehouse h mean for blanton's?
all blanton's comes from warehouse h at buffalo trace, a metal-clad warehouse. the metal cladding creates more temperature variation between seasons, which theoretically speeds up maturation and creates more interaction between the whisky and the wood. it's part of what made blanton's distinctive.
is blanton's available in india?
blanton's is occasionally available at duty free shops in indian airports, typically priced at rs 7000-9000. availability is inconsistent. if you see it, consider whether the price is justified given that buffalo trace's own budget offerings deliver comparable or better flavour.
what is the best value bourbon at duty free for indian buyers?
buffalo trace (the standard bottle) offers excellent value at duty free, usually rs 2500-3500. maker's mark and woodford reserve are also solid duty free picks. skip the hyped bottles like blanton's and pappy and look for honest, well-priced options instead.
why do single barrel bourbons vary in taste?
every barrel of bourbon ages differently depending on its position in the warehouse, the specific wood characteristics of that barrel, and temperature variations over the years. single barrel means no blending to create consistency. one barrel of blanton's might be excellent, the next might be average.
what proof is blanton's bourbon?
standard blanton's is 93 proof (46.5% abv). the single barrel format means each bottle comes from one barrel, though all blanton's barrels must pass through buffalo trace's warehouse h before bottling.
should i collect blanton's bottles?
the horse-and-jockey stoppers on blanton's bottles spell out b-l-a-n-t-o-n-s, and collecting the full set is a popular hobby. as collectibles, they're fun. as whisky investments, the hype far exceeds the liquid quality. buy bourbon to drink, not to display.